College and a parent’s responsibility
When the topic of college education comes up, there are generally two issues that come up. The parents will pay for their child’s college education, at the expense of their financial well-being and / or retirement fund. The flip side is the child ( young adult ) who is going to college, without parental assistance, and has resentment about it. Today I’m going to touch on the latter. Over at A Penny Saved, Sally wrote a post yesterday that caught my attention. It’s a great post actually, with her financial history / background. The part that I strongly disagree with is Sally’s resentment towards her father for not paying for her college education.
Granted, her father sounds like, well, an asshole – for lack of a better word. But he was ( by Sally’s own admission ) horrible with money, and had no skills in the way of money management. Her parents also had a total of 4 children, and lived in one of the most expensive parts of the country. If he had paid for her college, it likely would’ve put an insane amount of financial pressure on him. After all, it’s hard to give one of your kids a free ride to college and bail out on the other three – it’s sort of an all-or-nothing deal.
Your parents don’t owe you college
I’m not sure where in the parenting manual it states that you absolutely, positively must pay for your child’s college education. My manual did not come with that page. I have an 8 ( almost 9 ) year old son at home, and he means the world to me. When it’s time for him to go to college, I will provide free room & board. I won’t give him the boot at 18; he’s welcome to live with us through his college years. What I won’t do is jeopardize my financial health to pay for his college. He will work hard in school for the chance at scholarships. He will go to a two year community college at first, to reduce expenses. At that point he’ll go to a full-fledged university to finish his degree. How will it be paid for? A combination of scholarships, good old fashioned hard work, and student loans. My wife and I will impart as much financial wisdom as we can, so the student loan portion will hopefully be minimal. However, unless we are extremely wealthy, we will not pay for his college. The $40-$60 thousand ( ? ) that college could cost will be needed for our retirement funds.
Responsibility is a great teacher
If I write a tuition check every year, and send my child a check for expenses every month ( or worse yet give him a credit card ), I am not helping him. In fact, I am doing him a disservice. There is no better teacher in this world than responsibility. By working to get good grades, and working through college, he will have an enormous amount of respect for money. He will learn to keep expenses low, cut excess spending, and save where he can. If I hand him everything, he will not no respect for, and no concept of money. Once out of college, he will either linger at home on our dime ( without being motivated to set off on his own ), or he will go quickly into deep debt. By teaching him the value of hard work and money management, he is likely to avoid further debt and financial mistakes.
My college choice
I did not demand a free ride to college from my parents. Had I asked, they probably would have helped as they could. I refused to ask though – I knew, even at a young age, that it would not be responsible of me to ask. My folks are not wealthy people ( nor are they poor, just not well off enough to fund my college ). Instead I set out on my own, made my own mistakes, and learned my own lessons. I have not yet gone to college, but I may one day. At some point I may go, but currently I make more than all of my college-educated friends from the old days. If and when I do make the decision to pursue a higher education, it will be on my own dime, and no one else’s. And that will be something to be proud of.


February 11th, 2008 at 8:49 pm
I think you misinterpreted me: I don’t resent my father for not paying for my college education. I knew they didn’t have the money to pay for the full college educations of four children. I mean, who does, really?
What I resent him for, if anything, is being so demanding that my education not impact him financially at all (ie, no college for me until after I was 24 and his name was no longer on my FAFSA – sorry I wasn’t more explicit about that) and being eager to completely cut me off when I turned 18. His selfish attitude towards money, and well, everything, deeply influenced my own attitudes, and I’m still working on that today.
My mom ended up getting PLUS loans, but I’m the one who pays them. I resent **myself** for my college debts, because I made bad decisions. But I guess one thing I can be proud of is that I paid for my education myself. And the struggle *is* making me stronger.
I never said I think parents should pay for their children’s education – many can’t, so insisting upon it would be foolish. But the best gift I think the parents can give their children at this point in their lives is the reason *why,* as well as they have learned it. Even wealthy parents should let their children know *why* they can afford it. Let your children learn from your mistakes, your smart decisions; let them understand the cost of a year of college as compared to your income after expenses; tell them about how important it is for you to save for retirement (so they don’t have to support you later
); help them research scholarships and alternative education; help them understand what it is like to be in debt. Up until they are 18, most people in America have no experience of what it is like to personally be in debt, but *most* adult Americans are in debt. As a parent, you know what the real world is like.
I agree with you:
How will it be paid for? A combination of scholarships, good old fashioned hard work, and student loans. **My wife and I will impart as much financial wisdom as we can,** so the student loan portion will hopefully be minimal.
I hope any parents reading this will make an effort to think more like this.
February 11th, 2008 at 9:22 pm
I guess I didn’t quite take it the way you meant it. Cutting you off completely at 18 is a pretty rough way to handle things, and I can see that being a problem for you.
Slightly off-topic, FAFSA rules are absolutely absurd. Why should a parent’s finances be considered for a student’s ability to pay for college? I see zero connection between the two, and I think the rules need to be rewritten. Who is FAFSA to say what I can and cannot afford, and why should that affect my child?
February 11th, 2008 at 9:58 pm
Yeah, FAFSA… sucks. I’m not claimed on anyone’s taxes but my own, but FAFSA will still see me as a dependent for almost two more years. It’s just ridiculous. A good rant on the subject (no written by me) can be found here: http://poorerthanyou.com/2008/02/06/dependent-or-not-dependent-why-i-hate-the-fafsa/
February 11th, 2008 at 10:15 pm
That’s ridiculous… if you’re not a dependent on your taxes, then you shouldn’t be for FAFSA. Sigh. I love our country, but we have to have the most inefficient and illogical government in the world. That’s a good post by the way – really spells out the goofiness of the rules.
February 11th, 2008 at 11:33 pm
Ack. Should have been “not written by me” instead of “no written by me.” Darn sticky keyboard.
Thanks for the dialogue, by the way. It helps me feel like I have an audience and I’m not just talking to myself on the internet.
February 13th, 2008 at 8:52 am
I’m sure you have a lot more readers thank you think. Most readers are silent and don’t reply / comment. Look around the posts here and you’ll see the same thing happening
Lots of me talking to myself. But the readers are there for sure.
February 17th, 2008 at 7:40 pm
[...] presents College and a parent?s responsibility posted at Llama Money, saying, “Parents don’t need to pay for their children’s [...]
February 19th, 2008 at 9:01 am
Carnival of Everything Finance: #13…
Welcome to the February 15, 2008 edition of Carnival of Everything Finance.
We had over 130 really good articles submitted for this edition. Unfortunately I could not include all of them.
Earning Money
poetloverrebelspy presents Claim Your Ref…..
April 7th, 2008 at 12:36 pm
Just posted my thoughts on this subject over at my blog. Great post, with some great insights!
June 30th, 2008 at 1:21 pm
[...] at Llama money they had a similar discussion that struck a chord with me, so I thought I would give my take on this as [...]
July 17th, 2009 at 6:50 pm
How ill informed you are. The cost of an education has increased dramatically since the “olden days” when you were a student. The possibility of a student taking on loans of more than $50,000 is more than likely even if they do stay at home and attend a community college. As a professional working with college admissions, I am thoroughly shocked how often I meet parents who are completely unaware how much the world has changed. First of all “scholarships” or merit aid are more often then not for special talents. The largest part being a serious commitment to athletics. Grant aid, is generally need based. Meaning your parents are a liability even if they don’t wish to pay for your education. It is true that colleges will sometimes offer substantial merit aid for academics, but rarely more than 5-20% of tuition. As for study hard and get a scholarship. Study hard will mean that if you are lucky you are picked up by a high endowment college, where your parents Expected Family Contribution (EFC) could make college affordable for you if your family makes less than $60,000. However, travel and incidental costs will make this unlikely for 98% of students. In the past 10 years, I have worked with numerous National Merit Scholars and not one has received an academic scholarship of more than $15,000 anually to a private or public college. Get informed
July 17th, 2009 at 8:40 pm
Sharon,
I’m not sure when these “olden days” are. I’ve spent a grand total of 27 years on this fine earth. They do make these cool things called “jobs”, where you can “work” in exchange for “money.” This “money” can be used to pay for tuition. Since my son won’t be paying rent / utilities / food / etc, his expenses will pretty much consist of tuition and a bus pass. Not exactly gonna break the bank for him, and it will teach him a lot of responsibility. How exactly is that a bad thing?